|Pilot 1st Lt Charles E. Norton, O-416333 (POW, executed September 30, 1942, MIA) Harpswell, ME
Co-Pilot 1st Lt. Bruce B. S. Barker, O-428793 (MIA / KIA) Saskatoon, Canada
Navigator 1st Lt. Leo M. Eminger, O-388557 Upton, NM (MIA / KIA) NM
Bombardier Sgt James "Buster" R. Mathewson, 16028061 (MIA / KIA) Durand, MI
Radio SSgt Peter F. Novak, 6897614 (MIA / KIA) PA
Gunner SSgt William L. Hotard, 6296361 (MIA / KIA) TX
Lower Turret Gunner SSgt Fred S. Croyle, 6845914 (MIA / KIA) Somerset County, PA
Gunner Sgt Bruce W. Osborne, 7082892 (MIA / KIA, BR)
Gunner Pfc Edward A. Carroll, 6979511 (MIA / KIA) Brooklyn, NY
Ditched September 24, 1942
Built by Boeing at Seattle completed on November 17, 1941. Constructors Number 2231. Delivered to the U. S. Army Air Force (USAAF) as B-17E Flying Fortress serial number 41-2420 flown to Salt Lake City and three days later to Sacramento Air Depot (SAD).
On December 15, 1941 assigned
to the 11th Bombardment Group, 42nd Bombardment Squadron. On July 22, 1942 flown to Hickam
Field. During September 1942 ferried overseas to the South Pacific.
Nicknamed "Bessie, Jap
Basher" or "Bessie the Jap Basher". This B-17 was officially condemned on October 8, 1944.
On September 24, 1942 one of four B-17s that took off from Henderson Field on a bombing mission against Japanese shipping off Shortland
Island and Tonolei Harbor. Over the target area, approximately twenty Japanese Zeros made determined attacks against the formation from the front and both beams. Two of the attackers were claimed as shot down and another probably damaged. Despite the attacks, this B-17 dropped its bombs on a cargo vessel, which they claimed "took on a decided list" indicating it might have been hit. Damaged this B-17 was last seen descending smoking with fighters pursuing it. Flying at sea level, this B-17 managed to reach the north coast
of Guadalcanal and ditched into Domo Cove occupied by Japanese forces.
Fates of the Crew
At least two of the crew Norton and Osborne survived the ditching and managed to swim ashore. On September 30, Norton was captured by the Japanese Army, Aoba Battalion, Takeda Unit commanded by 1st Lt Yoshi Takeda. They claimed the prisoner "died
as [he] reached the place" (possibly meaning he was executed near Battalion headquarters).
During January 1944, the skeletal remains of Osborne were found near the shore of Domo Cove by U. S. Navy Seabees. It is unclear if he reached shore and died or was also captured and executed. The fates of the other crew are unknown, each is listed as Missing In Action (MIA).
On January 29, 1944 the 61st US Navy Seabees located the B-17 on its belly. Two days later, divers explored the wreckage and found no indication of a fire aboard, but noted bullet holes in the fuselage, and discovered four parachutes inside. The tail gunner's section was badly burnt. An explosion rear of the wings had broken the fuselage. The right wing was broken off at the body with only a small fragment intact. The engines were intact but between No.1 and No. 2 engines on the left wing was a large hole. Their search discovered no bones inside.
Captain George Sagli was present on the morning of January 31, 1944 when divers recovered the fuselage and tail assembly of the B-17. The wreckage had bullet holes in the fuselage and barnacles from being underwater for 16 months. The tail serial number "12420" was still clearly visible. No human remains or clothing were found aboard.
Inside the fuselage was a canteen with initials 'L.B' on the bottom. 50 caliber machine gun (from the waist) loaded, belted 50 caliber ammunition in an aluminum box, 50 caliber shell cases on the floor of the fuselage, fired, five parachutes (two numbered 39224 and 38165), frame less gold rimmed spectacles, Eveready flashlight, 8" wrench, 6" screw driver, hunting knife in a scabbard, a Colt 45 caliber M1911 pistol serial number 7797 in a holster with a knife, Mae West life vests, three with the CO2 containers unopened and a 30 caliber shell fired into the plane.
SF1C S. C. Kelly, 61st Seabees reported:
"On the morning of 31 January 1944 we searched in Domo Bay and found a B17 number 12420 on its belly offshore about 100 yards in 55 feet of water. There were innumerable small holes in the tail and the tail gun section had been burned badly. An explosion after of the wings had broken the fuselage from the main section of the pane although laying as it was it was impossible to get into that part of the plane.
The right wing was broken off at the body with the exception of a small fragment holding it on. The motors were intact but between the two motors on the left wing was a large hole as if it had collided with something. I hooked on to the tail skid and that section with par of the fuselage up to the wings was pulled ashore. The water was so riled it was impossible to see into the main section of the plane to examine further. To the best of my knowledge there were no bodied in that part of the plane that I could get into at that time."
On February 19, 1944 T/4 Robert W. Cannon, HQ Forward Area plus a CPO, three enlisted men and an officer of the 27th Seabees to examine the wreckage of the B-17 for bodies. They found several person effects, including the pilot's brief case with 'C.E. Norton' on it, but no bones.
On January 31, 1944 the rear fuselage and tail were salvaged by U. S. Navy Seabees and dragged ashore. The fate of this wreckage is unknown. Possibly, it was transported elsewhere during the war, scrapped or otherwise disappeared.
The wreckage of this B-17 rests in about 60' of water on a sandy bottom off
Domo Cove (Ndomo). All the
engines are intact on the plane, the nose section is collapsed,
but cockpit still in good condition with the pilot's seat and top turret intact. Other wreckage is scattered in the vicinity. The fuselage from the bomb bay to the tail was salvaged on January 31, 1944. The ball turret rests in the sand behind the fuselage.
Johnson dove the wreck in 1999:
"I dove the wreck 3 times and it is relatively
intact. Talking with the local dive master, he said that the locals
witnessed the crash and the Japanese captured two survivors who they
later executed. Another
thing I noticed is that two out of the four engines had been feathered."
The entire crew was officially declared dead on January 7, 1946 and all earned the Purple Heart, posthumously.
Norton earned the Distinguished Service Cross (DFC) and Silver Star. Barker earned the Distinguished Flying Cross (DFC) and Purple Heart with Oak Leaf Cluster. Eminger, Mathewson, Novak and Croyle each earned the Distinguished Flying Cross (DFC) and Air Medal with Oak Leaf Cluster. Hotard earned the Distinguished Flying Cross (DFC). Carroll earned the Distinguished Flying Cross (DFC) and Air Medal.
All are memorialized on the tablets of the missing at Manila American Cemetery. Bruce Osborne's local VFW post is named after him in his home town.
After the recovery of remains, Osborne was buried at Osborne Memorial Cemetery in Sparta, NC.
Eminger also has a memorial marker at Floyd Cemetery in Floyd, NM.
Mathewson also has a memorial marker at Caledonia Cemetery in Sparta, IL.
Croyle also has a memorial marker at IOOF Cemetery Stoystown, PA.
David Tanner (great nephew of Eminger)
"Leo Eminger was part of the 38th Recon Sq. from Albuquerque, NM. Eminger was awarded with the Distinguished Flying Cross, Air Medal with Oak Leaf Cluster and the Purple Heart. Eminger were both with the 88th Recon Squadron from Albuquerque Army Air Field. Eminger was with Crew No. 4 aboard B-17C 40-2063 one of the the B-17 flying from Hamilton Field bound for Hickam Field and arrived during the attack on December 7, 1941. Charles Norton was with Crew No. 6 which had to return to Hamilton Army Air Field due to engine trouble. I have also discovered, through many publications and personal contacts with crew families, photos of the pilot (Charles E. Norton), the co-pilot (Bruce B. S. Barker), and the bottom turret gunner (Fred S. Croyle). I am working on a photo of Bruce W. Osborne who is the only crew member listed as KIA because they found his bones."
Some sources state the nickname of this B-17 incorrectly as "Bessie the Jap Smasher"
USAF Serial Number Search Results - B-17E
Individual Aircraft Record Card (IARC) - B-17E 41-2420
Missing Air Crew Report (MACR) number unknown was created retroactively.
American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) - Charles E. Norton
American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) - Bruce B. S. Barker
American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) - Leo M. Eminger
American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) - James R. Mathewson
American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) - Peter F. Novak
American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) -
William L. Hotard
American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) - Fred S. Croyle
American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) - Edward A. Carroll
FindAGrave - Capt Charles Edwin Norton (photo, tablets of the missing)
FindAGrave - 1Lt Bruce Barnabas S Barker (tablets of the missing photo)
FindAGrave - 1Lt Leo M Eminger (photo, tablets of the missing)
FindAGrave - Leo M. Eminger (memorial marker)
FindAGrave - Sgt James R "Buster" Mathewson (tablets of the missing)
FindAGrave - Sgt James R Mathewson (memorial marker photo)
FindAGrave - SSgt Peter F Novak (tablets of the missing)
FindAGrave - SSgt William L Hotard (tablets of the missing)
FindAGrave - SSgt William L Hotard (tablets of the missing)
FindAGrave - Fred Schrock Croyle (memorial marker photo)
FindAGrave - Bruce Wayne Osborne (memorial marker photo)
FindAGrave - PFC Edward A Carroll (memorial marker photo)
Fortress Against the Sun, pages 269-270
Flight Journal Magazine by Franklin and Kathy Viola photographed wreckage, December 2000
Solomon Islands Diving "Bessie Jap Basher" by Mike McCoy
via Wayback Machine January 3, 2004
Freedom Newspapers "War Scrapbook" by Kevin Wilson September 9, 2005
Thanks to William Bartsch and David Tanner for additional photos, news articles and crew photographs.
Are you a relative or associated with any person mentioned?
Do you have photos or additional information to add?
February 14, 2020