Pacific Wrecks
Pacific Wrecks   Donate Now  
Search Chronology Locations Aircraft Vessels Missing In Action (MIA)
 
  B-17F-20-BO Flying Fortress Serial Number 41-24538  
USAAF
5th AF
43rd BG
403rd BS

Click For Enlargement
Click For Enlargement
Click For Enlargement
Jan 6, 1943 via Barr

Click For Enlargement
Click For Enlargement
Jan 6, 1943 via Barr

Click For Enlargement
Qantas 1943

Pilot  Captain Jean A. Jack, O-24178 (rescued) Tekamah, NB
Co-Pilot  1st Lt Arthur G. Durbeck, O-431269 (rescued)
Navigator  1st Lt James W. Knapp, O-860497 (rescued)
Bombardier  M/Sgt Harry Urban, 6979202 (rescued)
Engineer  T/Sgt John J. Meehan, 6949374 (rescued)
Radio  T/Sgt Carl P. Averill, 6149242 (rescued)
Asst Radio  Sgt David E. Carlson, 37086222 (rescued)
Ball Turret Gunner  Cpl Armando B. Mancini, 12024720 (WIA, rescued)
Gunner  Cpl Canaan (rescued)
Tail Gunner
 Sgt Dale F. Barr, 17038234 (rescued)

Ditched  January 5, 1943
MACR  none

Aircraft History
Built by Boeing at Seattle. Constructors Number 3221. Delivered to the U. S. Army. Ferried overseas via Hawaii to Australia.

Wartime History
Assigned to the 5th Air Force, 43rd Bombardment Group, 403rd Bombardment Squadron. No known nickname or nose art.

Mission History
On January 5, 1943 one of three B-17s from the 403rd Bombardment Squadron that took off from 7-Mile Drome near Port Moresby piloted by Captain Jean A. Jack on a bombing mission against Lakunai Airfield near Rabaul. This B-17 was one of three B-17s from the 403rd Bombardment Squadron along with B-17F "The Reckless Mountain Boys" 41-24518 and B-17E 41-2639 each armed with 100 pound general purpose bombs.

On the way, to the target, B-17F "The Reckless Mountain Boys" 41-24518 aborted due to engine problems. The approach to be made by coming over Raratuna Crater on heading at 1,700' making diving 90 degree turn crossing 2,000' and make 30 second run then make 100 degree turn away from the target area and return base.

The remaining two B-17s continued on making three dry runs over target but were unable to drop bombs because clouds obscured target. They experienced intense anti-aircraft over Simpson Harbor and were attacked by A6M Zeros of the 582 Kōkūtai. Four Zeros were claimed during an air battle between the target and 100 miles south of Rabaul, between 1000 hours and 1030 hours.

The official report says "Both old and new type Zero noted as well as E/A resembling ME-109. Enemy aircraft made determined attacks mostly from the front quarter". The 'ME-109s' were in fact Ki-43 Oscars of the 11th Sentai that had arrived from Truk to Rabaul. M/Sgt Urban, the navigator, Lt. Knapp, the radio operator, T/Sgt Averili and side gunner, CpI Canaan each claimed one plane shot down each. It is possible that one more enemy plane was shot down.

During the first pass by the enemy fighters, the ball turret was shot out and the radio compartment and No. 1 engine were shot and failed to feather, either hit by machine gun bullets or cannon shells (likely 13mm machine cannon of the Oscar or 20mm cannon shells). The left wing was shot through by a canon shell, just inboard the No. 1 nacelle damaging the main spar, engine controls, oil cooler and putting a hole in the gas tank.

Captain Jean A. Jack recalls the ditching:
"It was obvious that there was no way that I could get back, so I started deviating my course a little bit to the south and following the islands that are scattered out through there. Knowing that our final landing place was going to be the ocean itself, I started looking as I would pass by these islands. I was looking for huts, native huts, because I figured if there were native huts, people were living down there. That means there's food and water down there and so I thought that was pretty important. So I kept looking for something like that on the way and eventually I got to a place that there was an extinct volcano there, Urasi Island. It had, scattered in the palm trees along there, huts; you could see native huts. I figured we haven't got very much longer to stay up in this thing, so I told the radio operator to break radio silence and send a message back to our command that we were going down at sea and give them our position report."

This B-17 ditched in the sea roughly 200 yards offshore Urasi Island, northwest of the passage between Furgeson and Goodenough. Also lost on this mission was B-17F "San Antonio Rose" 41-24458 (MIA) last seen over the target area.

Arthur Durbeck adds:
"Our airplane was badly shot up. The ball turret was shot out. There were holes in the radio compartment. The No. 1 engine was shot through by either machine gun bullets or cannon shells. The left wing was shot through by cannon shell just inboard the No. 1 nacelle shooting out the main spar, engine controls, oil cooler and putting a hole in the gas tank. The engine failed to feather. Due to damage to the aircraft and loss of gasoline and weather it was necessary to make a crash landing at sea, there were no injuries to personnel due to the landing."

Fates of the Crew
The entire crew survived the ditching and successfully deployed both life rafts and paddled ashore to Urasi Island and awaited rescue.

Search
On January 6, 1943 two Allied aircraft searching independently located this downed B-17 and the crew. The first was a RAAF Beaufort from 100 Squadron. Also, B-17E "Blues in the Nite" 41-9209 piloted by Lt Compton dropped food supplies down to them. When found, it was hoped they were General Walker and the crew of B-17F "San Antonio Rose" 41-24458.

1st Lt Arthur G. Durbeck adds:
"On our return trip from a raid on Rabaul, we were attacked by three Zeros [Ki-43 Oscars] and shot up very badly. Our ball turret gunner [Mancini] was severely injured during the fight and sustained wounds in the left leg and left forearm. Our fuel tanks were holed in several places and our port outer engine went out of action.
After a long hard fight we at last managed to shake off the enemy planes and set out to try and reach our base. It was not long before the pilot realized that with one engine out of action and the loss of fuel we would never be able to make it.
The pilot [Jack] called the crew into the radio room and when they were assembled he explained the situation and said he would try and land on or near to an island. He then ordered the life rafts to be prepared and the wounded man was brought on to the flight deck. Everything went to plan until, within about a mile of the shore, the fuel suddenly gave out and the aircraft crashed into the sea. There were no casualties in the landing and within two minutes the entire crew were safely away in the raft.
We made for the shore which was about half a mile away and were met by a crowd of natives in their canoes. They proved to be very friendly and assisted us to a great degree. When we reached the shore which was about half a mile away and were met by a crowd of natives in their canoes. They proved to be very friendly and assisted us to a great degree. When we reached the shore the natives, one of whom could speak pidgin English led us to a large hut which was approximately one and a half miles from their village. After making us comfortable they then went away and returned with their arms full of tropical fruit.
I cannot speak too highly of the kindness of these simple people. As soon as we had made the gunner comfortable, the pilot called for two men to take a parachute to the highest point of the island and spread it out in the hopes that it might be seen from the air. We spent the night in the native hut and next day we saw your flying boat making in our direction. Our hopes rose high until we saw that it was making for another island, but after circling around it you came in our direction again and we realized that we had been found. Boy! We were glad to see your flying boat!"

Rescue
Later that day, the entire crew were rescued by S.25C "Coriolanus" VH-AKP piloted by Captain B. Hussey. The crew paddled out to the flying boat and returned to Fairfax Harbor off Port Moresby . Afterwards, the entire crew returned to duty.

Wreckage
This B-17 landed roughly 200 yards off Urasi Island with the tail section visible above water.

Rod Pearce adds:
"There is a wing up on the beach and a propeller was pulled from the wreck and ended up in some museum. The rest must be in water."

Relatives
Dale F. Barr, Jr. (son of Dale F. Barr)
"I have a scrapbook my father Dale Sr. (tail gunner) put together of the reconnaissance photos and photos from the Qantas air boat that picked them up from Urasi Island.  There are photos of the crew and a photo of my father receiving the Silver Star from General Kinney."

References
403rd Bomb Squadron History
"...after completing a successful daylight raid on Rabaul and shooting down four Zeros, [41-24538] was so badly crippled itself that it had to make a crash landing on a small island . . . due to the skill of the pilot . . . no one was injured. After a night spent ‘Crusoe Fashion’ on the island they were rescued by a RAAF flying boat"
News "An Air Rescue Captain Herbert Hussey"
Front-Line Airline The war story of Qantas Empire Airways Limited pages 155-157
"Finally Captain Hussey found that General Kenney was in [Port] Moresby and made an appointment with him. The General said that the aircraft was a B-17 and the circumstances justified special efforts. Its location was stated and General Kenney wished Captain Hussey to offload the wounded and proceed as quickly as possible. This was done and a doctor and medical attendant were included in the personnel.
On the way to the island, an escort of Allied fighters picked up the flying boat and gave top cover in the event of running into Japanese aircraft. This was the first time a lone Qantas aircraft had had protection.
The locality indicated was searched without result, but after circling for some minutes over Urasi Island, the party was quickly located. Setting the flying down on the open sea was not easiest task but it was safely done, and the flying boat taxied close inshore.
Hardly had the flying boat touched the water than one of the castaways crew came out in a rubber boat. He reported that the whole crew ere there, 9 in all. The co-pilot of B-17F 41-24538 was Lieutenant Durbeck who told the story of their adventure."
PNG Museum Aircraft Status Card - B-17F Flying Fortress piloted by Jack
The Queensland Book of Memories: Herbert Bindley Hussey
Pride of Seattle pages 13-14
janus.mtsu.edu - Jean Jack (via WaybackMachine)
General Kenney Reports pages 176, 177
Front Line Airline mentions this incident
Obituary Col. (Retired) Jean A. Jack 1915 ~ 2006
The War Diaries of Eddie Allan Stanton, page 114
"January 1943, Gumasila Island a B-17 crashed a week or so ago no airmen killed. I found log, took off from 7-Mile to Gasmata then over Buka at 28,500') and back to 7-Mile via Woodlark. Pilot Smyth Navigator Knapp' Crashed on other side of the island into the water 50m from shore, tail above the water. Did not take anything, nothing to take. Morning natives brought two rifles crew left behind. Many shells casings near village."
Letter Dale F. Barr to Eugene Monihan September 25, 1991
"When the flying boat landed and taxied as close to the island that he dared, we paddled out to him in our life boats and I will never forget the events that followed. The pilot stuck his head out the window and shouted to us 'Is this General Walker's crew?' I answered, "No this is Jack's crew from the 403rd Bomb Squadron". The pilot replied "are you sure this isn't General Walker's crew? Again I told him who we were. To this day I think he was ready to pull out and leave us there. He was so disappointed that we weren't General Walker's crew, but of course I see it another way! I wonder if they had known higher up that this wasn't General Walker's crew, if they would have sent the flying boat up to rescue us. We'd probably still be sitting there, ha ha. This is just one of the memorable moments of that ill fated day."
Ken’s Men Against The Empire pages 99 (map), 101-107, 209 (painting)
Thanks to Steve Birdsall, Eugene Monihan and Dale Barr, Jr. for additional information

Contribute Information
Are you a relative or associated with any person mentioned?
Do you have photos or additional information to add?

Last Updated
November 13, 2017

 

Tech Info
B-17

Photos
Photo Archive

    All rights reserved.  
  Pacific Wrecks Inc. is a non-profit 501(c)(3) charity dedicated to bringing home those Missing In Action (MIA) and leveraging new technologies in the study of World War II Pacific and the Korean War.  
Facebook Twitter YouTube Google Plus Instagram
 
Forum Updates People Museums Reviews Submit Info How You Can Help